I guess I'll resurrect this thread.
I did some research and decided to strip and polish my scoops. There's a local metal shop that will do all the work for about $36 max. I'll gladly pay that and save my time. The guy I left them with knew the metal and confident about what he will do. I would rather chrome them, but living in Hungary limits my options GREATLY. I cannot find a shop that chromes things here. I know Sean Morley does, but there's the problem of shipping overseas.
I completely understand if left simply polished, it will require maintenance. I already have polished aluminum external items on my vehicles and I just hit them with Mother's metal polish once a month or so and they look like new. I also have Nevr-Dull, but it doesn't seem to work well.
$36 is a fantastic deal - go for it! Stripping and polishing the scoops is a labour intensive and long job - ask anyone that has done it.
Yes, you are right - chroming is the best option. No maintenance other than cleaning and light polishing. Polishing the
aluminum requires constant maintenance. Simply put - the bare polished aluminum will start to tarnish the minute you stop polishing! Which is why you have to protect it with a barrier coating ( Mother's wax, etc.) or a clearcoat as soon as you've polished, and on a regular basis to maintain the luster.
This tarnishing characteristic of aluminum is why the OEM "polished" aluminum parts of the Max(scoops, rims, sidecovers, etc.) are clear-coated at the factory - tarnished shiny parts would not look good on the showroom floor.
"Never-Dull" is great for removing water marks, and
preparing aluminum for polishing - it is too abrasive for the final look.
I spent years stripping, polishing and protecting the aluminum parts on my bike. WAY too much work and maintenance, i.m.o. I'd rather be riding the bike, instead of prettying it up. Which is why I'm becoming a big fan of the
blacked-out look. Any parts intended to be shiny are made out of
stainless steel - much harder to work with and polish, but not subjected to corroding, like aluminum.
Cheers!