I like both, for different reasons. The chrome look is more-'bright' (read, 'flashy').
I have multiple tins and other pieces like the scoops and side covers that are all finished differently. I can have a stock-looking bike or I can add different color & polished powder-coated, or chrome pieces to change the look. I have several seats too, and I would have had 3 different exhausts if I hadn't sold my Kerker 4/1 on here recently. Mix & match! I even have the luxury of different rear fenders. I have a custom front that I haven't gotten-around to mounting.
Like your GF or wife, change your look of your bike to keep things interesting or to suit your purpose. She gets a new handbag, you fit your saddlebags. She gets a new hair style, you go from a grab bar hugging the rear fender, to a powder-coated sissy bar & luggage rack. She gets a new summer outfit, you get a bright swap-out of the F & R fenders & the faux tank cover.